
Following the "Three Events=Trend" story, we'll take the publication of yesterday's
Fearful rich keep poor at bay with gated homes and razor wire story in the
Guardian as an excuse to ramble about the phenomenon of the gated communites--
los countries--so popular in the Buenos Aires suburbs. The
Guardian piece, which claims there to be 400
countries with 300,000 residents, follows on the heels of a February
Clarín piece (
Ya está fuera de las aulas la primera "generación country") and a Christmas Day NYT piece (
A Widening Gap Erodes Argentina’s Egalitarian Image), all of which focus to various degrees on the increasing
desigualidad and fear that create and are caused by the
countries and the generation of hyper-protected children brought up in the weird bubble of
country living. As the
Guardian writer Rory Carroll notes:
Those outside the fences joke that the children inside think golf carts are mankind's main mode of transport and have no idea what traffic lights are for.
Film director
Celina Murga, 34, who made the lovely, small film
Ana y los otros, is now making
Una semana solos (
A Week Alone), a movie about gated community kids who are left unsupervised. It is, Carroll says, "more Lord of the Flies than Home Alone."
"The children growing up in these places are very different from others, they don't know how to behave in the real world," says Murga. "Instead of trying to build a circle of protection around them we need to build human beings who can deal with the world as it is. I want to show that this is a social crisis."
Not only do the kids grow up in surreal bubbles, the poverty and crime that the residents entered these sealed villages to avoid do not necessarily stay away: the outside castle-like barriers of many
countries often serve as the perfect back wall to the shanty town
villas oft-founded just outside (see picture, above) and often filled with the manual laborers who work inside during the day. And the crime rate? According to a February La Nación article (
En lo que va del año, se cometió un delito cada tres días en algún country), there's a robbery every three days in a country.
9 Comments:
I have friends that live in a country and have 5 children ages 1 to 14 and are going through some of these issues. There´s a very interesting note of Spanish woman that describes the social effects in children at BARRIOS CERRADOS Y SEGREGACIÓN SOCIAL URBANA. One of the points that she mentions is the lack of limits in the children inside the barrios even reaching infant vandalism.
I wonder why we shouldn´t compare the walls around barrios cerrados with other more infamous walls (Berlin, Palestina, Southern border of US with Mexico...).
Well, maybe we don´t because of the scale. But isn´t it always the same idea? Keeping the Others out and the Ones in?
In the old times (meaning the China wall or the fortified cities) the walls included all social classes inside... but still it was the idea of defense from the foreign invasive cultures or attacks that could destroy their own...
Interesting no? Borders are borders and anybody is free to autosegregate or to transcend them.
Myself? I believe in building bridges.
99: I think the difference is that people living behind the "country" wall are allowed to enter and leave as they please.
You may argue kids are kept beind the gates; but isn´t that more a parenting issue than a gated community issue?
I´ve lived all my life in gated communities, always had more friends "outside" than "inside", the difference is I´ve been able to leave my bike outside my door and find it in the same place the next morning.
Interesting debate though...
(and kudos to GoodAirs for being a great blog!)
Can I ask you both in you beleive in freedom of the press and the right to disagree why then do you promote a known fascist on your blog who has been causing tremendous problems thru Buenos Aires with her vicious blog Quesedicenellos.
Mercedes stuart who does not even live in Argentina is trying to shut people up about the truth in Argentina.
Freedom to print without fear is the fundamental right of journalism
And the crime rate? According to a February La Nación article (En lo que va del año, se cometió un delito cada tres días en algún country), there's a robbery every three days in a country.
That is a spectacularly low crime rate, especially for Argentina. Think about it: Out of all the countries in BsAs a robbery occurred only once every three days. Wow.
If the Guardian piece is correct and there are 400 countries then that means that less than 3.5% of the countries even had a robbery at all, during the first quarter.
This is exactly why people are moving to the countries. It's not hard to figure out. ;)
estimado anonymous,
Posting sharp accusations ("known fascist") without explanation or evidence and doing so under an anonymous handle are not two tastes that go great together. So please post and explain under your own name or desist.
Gracias!
Ian
Having a name anonymous does not make my points any less valid in what I am saying here.
Have you both noticed that a great blogger called Mad Max from Comments from Argentina has been silenced.
I believe in freedom of the press soemthing many people want to deny.
Doh. Looks like my comment got lost in the series of tubes. :S
Basically, I mentioned that the "crime rate" cited is spectacularly low. Only one robbery every three days across 400 neighborhoods is impressive...especially for Argentina.
I notice that you repeatedly misspell the word "heel" as "heal". As a writer this bothers me, especially when it comes from another writer. Aside from that nitpick, this is a great blog. I've read nearly the entire thing in one sitting.
I understand that this comment will be moderated, which is why I feel free to make it. I wouldn't publicly "call you out" so to speak. I have more professional courtesy than that.
You are correct sir! Poor form--bad writer, bad. Well, it's now been corrected.
Post a Comment
Links to this post:
Create a Link
<< Home